"If a tree falls in a forest … does it make a sound?” While an interesting philosophical query about perception, in the real world it doesn’t take the sound to know that trees have fallen. The fact that they are lying on the ground should be evidence enough.
These thoughts came to mind when I listened to President Trump’s irrational nonsense about COVID-19 testing and its relationship to the number of documented coronavirus cases and deaths in the United States. The President is calling for the American people to practice willful ignorance of the facts. Of course, there is nothing new to Trumpian denial of facts and assertion of an alternate reality (or as Trump counselor Kelly Ann Conway asserted on the third day of the Trump administration, that there are “alternative facts”).
But let’s look at what the President said last week on a day when the United States passed 1.4 million in confirmed COVID-19 cases and nearly 86,000 confirmed deaths. (Most public health experts, scientists and statisticians say those numbers are underreported, including White House Coronavirus Task Force member Anthony Fauci.)
Here is what President Trump said: “So we have the best testing in the world. It could be the testing’s, frankly, overrated? Maybe it is overrated? … And don’t forget, we have more cases than anybody in the world. But why? Because we do more testing. When you test, you have a case. When you test you find something is wrong with people. If we didn’t do any testing, we would have very few cases. They don’t want to write that. It’s common sense. We test much more.”
Now there is so much misleading and false information we can download from that statement, in keeping with the more than 18,000 documented instances since Inauguration Day. But let’s focus on the call to willful ignorance built into the President’s faulty logic.
Former White House Press Secretary Joe Lockhart crystallized it: "Let me see if I understand his [Trump’s] logic. If you don’t test, there would be fewer cases … ergo, the testing causes coronavirus. Glad he straightened that out.”
The number of coronavirus cases (and deaths) is not because of testing, it is revealed by testing. The cases and the deaths are reality, Mr. President, reality. Like the trees that silently fell to the forest floors, COVID-19 numbers are real. Count them and weep.
The numbers cannot be willed away, just as the virus cannot be willed away. Denial does not change reality.
The President’s fixation on numbers is a continuum and it reveals a presidential concern about political perception, not human suffering and death. And it reveals a desire to lower the numbers not by concerted governmental action to actually fight the pandemic, but by rhetorical device because they are politically inconvenient.
Remember the instance over the docking of the coronavirus-infected cruise ship, the Grand Princess, off the coast of San Francisco? On March 6th, the President said he’d rather have the people stay on board the ship because the arrival of more infected people would raise the case count of the United States: “I’d rather have the people stay. I would rather — because I like the numbers being where they are — I don’t need to have the numbers double because of one ship …”
It is patently clear that this president wants us to buy the “alternative facts” that we are not suffering through a pandemic. We are asked to believe in the silence of the trees: just because they are lying on the forest floor does not mean that they fell. We didn’t hear them. He is calling on us to be willfully ignorant of the facts, because the facts are inconvenient to his quest for another four years in office.
Evan Barrett lives in historic Uptown Butte after retiring following 47 years at the top level of Montana economic development, government, politics and education. He is an award-winning producer of Montana history videos who continues to write columns and commentaries and occasionally teaches Montana history.
Catch the latest in Opinion
Get opinion pieces, letters and editorials sent directly to your inbox weekly!