Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Metals, acid in Berkeley Pit water killed geese, report confirms

Metals, acid in Berkeley Pit water killed geese, report confirms

From the Here's what happened after thousands of geese landed on the Berkeley Pit series

The estimated 3,000 to 4,000 snow geese that perished in December 2016 in the Berkeley Pit’s toxic water died of both heavy metals and sulfuric acid, according to U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service spokesperson Ryan Moehring.

The necropsy report does not make the findings clear, stating only that lesions in the stomach, intestines, and throats were severe and “suggestive of chemical tissue damage induced by a corrosive substance.”

Copper and zinc, both of which were found inside the birds’ stomachs, could have been the cause or a contributing factor in the lesions, according to the report. Other metals, including manganese, were found in the organs of the geese.

Montana Resources manager of environmental affairs Mark Thompson said the report’s findings that the metals and acid in the pit caused the bird mortalities came as no surprise.

“There was never any suspicion the birds died from some other cause besides pit water,” Thompson said.

The companies responsible for the pit, Montana Resources and Atlantic Richfield Co., could be fined as much as $5,000 per bird. Helena-based U.S. Attorney spokesperson Melissa Hornbein said the U.S. Attorney’s Montana office cannot comment yet on whether the companies will be fined.

The report says 18 birds were tested. Two of the birds were different species of duck. The other 16 were snow geese.

One bird the lab tested was shot in Dillon. That bird died of the gunshot wound. A captured and treated bird, which died after capture, was also sent to the necropsy lab. That bird showed inflammation and bacteria internally in addition to internal damage caused by metals and sulfuric acid. The infection may have contributed to that bird’s death, according to the report.

The report says the birds’ condition was similar to the 342 snow geese that died in November 1995 when a flock landed — almost 21 years to the day — on the pit during a snowstorm and perished. Those birds were found dead by a Bureau of Mines and Geology employee who returned to the pit’s toxic water within a few days to take water samples after the storm passed.

When a winter storm encouraged the birds to land in 2016, an estimated 10,000 birds found a resting spot on the Berkeley Pit, but thousands of birds flew off over the course of a week. A Bureau of Mines and Geology water sample report taken in December of last year found the pit’s water to be less acidic than it was in 1995.

Earlier this year the companies put together a bird advisory committee and hired Montana Tech professor Stella Capoccia to advise on new ways to prevent birds from landing and dying in the pit in the future. The companies are testing new technologies this spring. In addition to propane-powered canons already stationed around the pit, the companies are bringing in later this month a device that shoots out rings of compressed air that scare the birds, Thompson said. The companies hope to have a fully vetted plan in place by fall to prevent another die-off. The plan will have to get federal and state agency approval.

The news from the necropsy report comes just in time for a bird mourning event hosted by the Clark Fork Watershed Education Program and Butte’s Citizens for Labor and Environmental Justice. Taking place from 3 to 6 p.m. Saturday at the Knights of Columbus's upstairs ballroom, the event is a fundraiser for CFWEP, which seeks to educate the region’s youth on the local environment. Event spokesperson Mary Kay Craig said there will be art, music, poetry, presentations, and snow geese commemorative items for sale.

Craig said the event is intended to help the community of Butte heal.

“The purpose is for people to acknowledge the horrible way these creatures died and get some closure,” Craig said.


Get local news delivered to your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Environmental and natural resources reporter for the Montana Standard.

Related to this story

  • Updated

As 2017 comes to a close, we look back at some of the most important, interesting and unusual stories this year in the Mining City.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News