Guest view icon

For the last 150 years, Montana American Indians have experienced a wave of immigrants known as white men, the majority now. The U.S. Census Bureau projects that within 40 years, our majority population will not be white. Some believe this is because most of our new immigrants are people of color.

Thus, our immigration debate is no longer the four pillars of the 2013 Marco Rubio proposal, emphasizing education and employer responsibility. In April of 2017, Arkansas's Tom Cotton and Georgia's David Perdue proposed legislation with a 50 percent reduction in annual immigration over the next 10 years, from 1,051,031 in 2015 to 539,958 in 2027.

At his State of the Union address, Donald Trump announced his new four pillars, including citizenship for "dreamers," border security, and ending diversity visas and family reunification. The emphasis is no longer employment status, it is skin color.

My family, Otjen, came from the Elbe-Weser Triangle or Lower Saxony area of what is now Germany. They settled in Wisconsin, currently represented by Speaker of the House Paul Ryan, who is complicit with Trump's use of immigrants as political pawns. In 1905, Wisconsin was represented by my great-uncle, Republican Congressman Theobald Otjen, the son of immigrant Conrad Otjen.

Conrad arrived in the U.S. in 1827 and became a citizen in 1836. John Otjen arrived in 1817, Harm in 1823, Hinrich in 1852 and Friedrich in 1854, all from the same immediate family. They were a chain being reunified from an area that at the time was rife with revolution and upheaval. They came to the promised home of the brave as part of what would be called the homeless tempest, an angry and violent world.

Their descendants include Major General John P. Otjen and William J. Otjen, who was National Commander and Chief of Foreign War Veterans in 1932, my grandfather.

Every family from every immigrant should be as proud and welcome as mine. It appears, for example, that most of the Gianfortes arrived from Italy between 1862 and 1892 (i.e., Montana's U.S. Rep. Greg Gianforte).

Still, Republicans seem to think that because most of us are no longer tired and poor, there is no more room for the wretched refuse. Especially if the teeming shores are on brown people countries. They want to eliminate reunification even when the wait times for a spouse, child, brother or sister is as long as 15—20 years. About 225,000 immediate family-based visas are issued annually.

They want to eliminate the diversity lottery, which accounts for about 50,000 fully vetted immigrants. Using diversity as a criteria has made it possible for almost half of these visas to be given to immigrants from Africa, or what Trump referred to as "sh-thole countries."

Border security includes limiting asylum cases even though less than 5 percent come from south of the Mexican border. There will be no lamps lifted beside the golden $20 billion Trump wall.

On Dec. 17, 2017, Paul Ryan said, "We have a 90 percent increase in the retirement population of America but only a 19 percent increase in the working population ... we need more people."

The Republicans' answer for this problem is a tax plan without family leave or corporate day care credits and a new anti-abortion bill. They must not be including women in their working population. But they are counting on the number of new white babies to make up for a reduction in brown immigrants.

It's a fallacy. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the dominant race in the future will be "none of the above." Our races will be diverse. They will be mixed. They will be American.

A.J. Otjen traces her Republican roots to her great-grandfather Theobald Otjen, congressman from Wisconsin in 1905, and her grandfather William Otjen of Oklahoma. She teaches courses at the College of Business at Montana State University-Billings and has a PhD in social sciences.


Load comments